2004 has been a great year in music. Two bands that had debut CDs this year are now two of my favorites: The Killers and Scissor Sisters. And Scissor Sisters' debut album is so far my favorite album of the year...one of the best albums I've heard in several years. It's been a while since a debut album had gotten me that excited about a band. In fact, the last time a debut album made me that giddy was Ben Folds Five...
It was back in 1996 that I read a blurb in Entertainment Weekly about this band called Ben Folds Five that said the Five had echoes of Elton John in his early prime (a comparison that would later be also attributed to Scissor Sisters). So, I went to Newbury Comics in Harvard Square and picked up a copy of the album. I instantly fell in love. After years of listening to long-time established artists like Elton John, Billy Joel, Queen, and The Beatles, I had finally found a band from my generation that totally clicked with me. Later that summer, I saw them live with my friends Mike and Albie in West Palm Beach's Carefree Theater. That totally sealed my love for the band. They had won a fan for life. As you all probably know, the band broke up in 2000 with Ben forging on with a solo career. Through all the ups and downs, I've stayed a fan buying every album, every EP, and going to every Ben Folds Five/Ben Folds concert I could go to (before last night, a total of eleven if I'm counting correctly: Carefree Theater in '96, Paradise Rock Club in Boston in '97, The Roxy in Boston in '97, the WBCN Christmas concert in '97, University of Rhode Island in '99, two El Rey shows in L.A. in '01, two El Rey Shows in L.A. '02, The Palace in Hollywood '02, and the Greek Theater in '03).
Flash forward to a month or so ago, I made a visit to the Ben Folds website (my first visit in a few months) and noticed a Ben Folds concert listing for Los Angeles. It seemed odd that he'd be making a stop at a kinda-major venue like the El Rey for a two-night run without a new album to promote. After some further research, I saw that it kinda lined up with the album release for the William Shatner he produced. Could it be? A Shatner/Folds show? At the show I saw Ben Folds do at The Palace, Shatner made do a cameo during Ben's encore and performed "In Love." However, when I received the tickets for this El Rey show, they only said "Ben Folds" on them. Still, I heard rumors that Shanter will be performing...If it was true, I wondered, in what capacity would he perform?
I arrived at the El Rey at 7 PM Friday night and there was already a line stretched to the sidewalk corner. I took my place at the end of the line next to a boy studying for his SATs. High schoolers listen to Ben Folds? Go figure...My friend Jon arrived around 7:30-ish and met me in line. The line at this point had extended around the block...A camera crew was walking down the line. Apparently, this show was being taped for a DVD. Hmmm...
We entered the El Rey around 8 PM. We made our way towards the front hoping to see if there were any tables and seats free in the raised level. But alas, the tables were removed. No worries though...there's an open nook towards the front of the raised area. We had a prime view of the stage, as you'll see in the pics below...
It's a bit after nine (9:15 or 9:30...I forget...) and Ben hit the stage along with a drummer and bassist. Ben had a backing band this time! After two years of seeing him totally solo, this was quite a treat. And it's JUST a bassist and drummer along with him...it wasn't Robert Sledge and Darren Jessee, though. :-/ Needless to say, it was a bit weird seeing the instrumental makeup of Ben Folds Five, but not the same faces.
Here's what was played (to the best of my memory):
In Between Days
Zak and Sara
All U Can Eat
Hiro's Song (with maracas!)
New Song #1!! (the lyrics mentioned "I have you to blame for this" and "tattoos")
New Song #2!! (had "goodbye" in falsetto a lot in the chorus)
Gone
New Song #3!! (the lyrics mentioned "it's been too late for too long")
Carrying Cathy
There's Always Someone Cooler Than You
- band goes off stage -
Boxing
Gracie Girl
Where's Summer B? (audience backup vocals!)
Brick
Army (more audience backup vocals!)
- band returns while Ben demonstrates why he should do film scores -
Philosophy
Rockin' the Suburbs
Get Your Hands Off Of My Woman
Not the Same (three-part audience backup vocals!)
Really strong set of songs with a good sampling of all the different albums. Lots of early Halloween treats including hearing "All U Can Eat" and "There's Always Someone Cooler Than You" live with bass and drum parts. And of course, the three new songs. Does anybody out there have the titles to them? "New Song #1" had an awesome piano part. "New Song #2" was a great ballad with a little country twinge to it. "New Song #3" was a strong mid-tempo number. All of the new songs were really good..catchy, with good hooks and chord changes. What I noticed is that the songs seemed a bit more mature with a couple dealing with marriage, but each had little humorous twists in the lyrics without undermining the song. I have to say, I really hadn't given Ben Folds too much thought this year, but this concert really opened up my ears again and reminded me of why I love his music so much. It was like reuniting with an old friend you hadn't seen in a while. I'm so stoked to hear the new album!
Now...had the concert been all finished by this point, I would have been a happy camper. But noooo...after "Not the Same," there wasn't the usual encore...there was a bit of shuffling around on stage, because...yes...it was true...William Shatner was about to take stage with Ben. Not only that, Joe Jackson was joining them as well!!! Before we knew it, there they were performing the title track from William Shatner's "Has Been" album. But wait, there was more...four more songs from "Has Been" along with a couple of extra guests including Henry Rollins (!!!) joining the Shatner for one number and I believe Fleming of Fleming and John providing backing vocals on another. The last song performed from "Has Been" was the cover of "Common People" and it was AMAZING. The energy and intensity were mind-blowing. I never thought I would say this, but Shatner ROCKED. The crowd and I went insane. They left the stage after the number...but the house music didn't pop up.
There would be an encore?? What could they possibly do to top this? Another "Has Been" number? A Ben solo number? Ben and the band returned to the stage...along with Joe Jackson...and Shatner. Shatner shot his fist up in the air and proceeded to give everybody the finger. The crowd went wild again! What was going on here? Ben started playing the electronic keyboard. As he played the intro to the final encore...the notes sounded familiar...
OH...MY...GOD...
He was playing the intro to
"Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds." I think I'll repeat that again to show you that I am not joking...HE WAS PLAYING THE INTRO TO
"LUCY IN THE SKY WITH DIAMONDS!!!" William Shatner was going to do "Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds" as his encore! He recited the verses in a way that only he could. It was a bit off, but it was done with such gusto that you overlooked that. Joe and Ben popped in for the chorus. And in minutes, it was all over...This concert which almost flew under the radar for me was history. This concert which will go down as one of the most memorable concerts I've ever seen was through. Amazing...Truly amazing...
And now, I share the pics I took from the show...Enjoy...







Now, off to bed... :-)